TGEU
Countries: Hungary
On some occasions, when civil society has called on the
lebrities and crimes. Most stories involve events outside
The Fundamental Rights Agency’s EU LGBT survey
authorities to condemn these statements, the author-
of Hungary, and it is very rare that a piece on Hungarian
from 201215 found that 50 per cent of trans respond-
ities have remained silent. As a result of the climate of
issues is published. Stories by the Hungarian news agen-
ents from Hungary said that in the year preceding the
impunity, derogatory remarks about trans persons have
cy Hungarian Telegraphic Office are sometimes popular
survey they had felt personally discriminated against or
become commonplace in the public sphere.
and published online by many news sites. Even when
harassed because they were perceived as trans. Those
the stories are well-intentioned, the language used has
who had been discriminated against or harassed were
For the record
plenty of room for improvement. To address this prob-
more likely to avoid expressing their preferred gender
1. Jobbik held a press conference entitled “Our Europe
lem, in 2015 a guide on LGBTI issues was prepared by
than those who had not (60%, versus 40% in the EU as
vs. the Europe of the bearded woman”. Conchita
the Hungarian LGBT Alliance and TV, as well as a trans/
a whole). Those who had been discriminated against or
Wurst was presented as an example of the latter and
intersex-specific guide by TV.
harassed were also more likely to avoid certain places or
contrasted with examples of the former.
locations for fear of being assaulted, threatened or har-
2. After Conchita Wurst won the Eurovision Song Con-
assed than those who had not (68%, versus 32% in the
test, and in the run-up to the European Parliament
((missing picture))
Comparison between the general population’s and trans persons’
perception of discrimination on the ground of gender identity.
EU as a whole).
elections the same month, Jobbik published a picture
showing Conchita Wurst over an EU flag alongside
To assess how trans respondents’ perceptions of dis-
gender identity or gender expression, and only 4 of the
a blonde Hungarian woman over the Hungarian flag,
crimination on the grounds of gender identity compare
66 respondents who answered in the affirmative filed a
with the words “You choose!” A spokesman for the
with those of the general population, data from the EU
complaint. In two of the cases, the healthcare facilities
LGBT survey are presented in the following chart along-
in question were not dealing with the complaints, and in
side those from the Special Eurobarometer 393. Trans
the two other cases an investigation had been initiated
respondents in the EU LGBT survey are more likely than
but there had been no follow-through. The majority of
Eurobarometer survey respondents to say that discrimi-
respondents (94%) did not report the incident because
party had previously said Jobbik opposed “bearded
women”.
3. The day after Conchita won Eurovision, Jobbik’s
Youth Division posted a meme on its Facebook page.
Guide for journalists
by Transvanilla and
the Hungarian
LGBT Alliance
On the left side of the picture was Conchita and a slo-
As a result of the issues described above, many trans
nation based on a person’s gender identity is widespread
they feared getting into a worse situation, did not think
gan “Their Europe”, and on the right was a family and
people feel devastated from time to time. In the Tran-
in their country of residence. It is important to highlight
they could do anything, were afraid of being humiliated
the slogan “Our Europe”. The post generated 4,962
sCare survey, 53.7 per cent of respondents reported
again that only 3 per cent of Hungarian respondents in
or hurt, believed that the incident was too minor or had
likes, 223 comments and 5,091 shares.
that they have seriously considered committing suicide
the Eurobarometer survey know a trans person.
no trust in the authorities.
According to Transvanilla’s study ’The situation of trans-
One of the root causes of discrimination and inappropri-
Transvanilla has been monitoring Hungarian mass me-
sexual people in Hungary in 2012’, transsexual people
ate care in the healthcare system is the lack of medical
dia since October 2014 with regard to its coverage of
most often experienced discrimination at the hands of
guidelines for trans-specific healthcare. Psychiatrists,
and 44.4 per cent of those – every fourth person surveyed – has actually tried to commit suicide.
+ 40 +
trans and intersex issues and the (mis)representation of
Societal violence
their schoolmates (38%) and in the healthcare system
surgeons and other medical staff providing trans-specif-
trans and intersex people. There is not much coverage
Since Hungary has been a member of the EU, solid data
(34%). The high level of healthcare discrimination is also
ic healthcare are free to decide whom to treat, whether
of trans issues in the media, and most of the articles can
on discrimination against trans people has been collect-
underlined in Transvanilla’s TransCare research: 26 % of
to treat them and how to treat them. In one case, a psy-
be grouped into the following categories: transsexual
ed through some EU-wide research and by research
respondents felt discriminated against in healthcare fa-
chiatrist’s lack of knowledge resulted in his requesting
“family” stories, issues involving public washrooms, ce-
studies by Hungarian LGBT and trans organisations.
cilities or during medical examinations because of their
legal gender recognition as a prerequisite for the diag-
+ 41 +