TGEU
Countries: Turkey
Interview with hayat,
a trans woman who was refused access to healthcare services
In the educational system, bullying, discrimination and
Societal violence
even violence from other students, their teachers and
Trans people face stigmatisation from the very beginning
the administration are common experiences among
of their lives. Having a non-conforming gender identity
Could you tell us about the discrimination you faced at the
As far as I know, the case was brought to trial.
trans youth. TGEU’s TvT Survey on the Social Experiences
or gender expression results in stigmatisation and social
hospital, which was also reflected in the media? What have
What stage is it at now? What has happened?
of Trans and Gender-diverse People (TvT survey) 6 reveals
exclusion. In the TvT survey, of the 108 of 109 respond-
you gone through?
On the day of the case, the minutes were taken and sent to the Chief
some worrisome trends in Turkey’s educational system:
ents who answered the question on discrimination from
On 31 March 2014, after my sex-reassignment surgery at the
Physician. A case was presented against the doctor on the basis of
society, 66 per cent stated that they always experience
same hospital, in accordance with the guidance of the senior
malpractice and discriminatory and insulting behaviour. The gov-
discrimination from society, while only 2 per cent feel
general surgeon, I went to the Beyoglu District Polyclinic’s De-
ernor ruled that charges could not be pressed against her. In the
that they have never been discriminated against.
partment of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, which is linked to the
expert witness report, which constituted the basis for this decision,
Prof Dr Resat Belger Training and Research Hospital, in order to
it was proposed that she should receive a disciplinary punishment
Trans women and trans men experience different types
receive a prescription for my medication. Although the special-
from the Istanbul Chamber of Medicine. We are awaiting the re-
of discrimination and violence. Consistently with the
ist doctor stated that this was not her area of expertise, I sensed
sults of the investigation by prosecutor’s office. The case has been
dominant patriarchal system, femininity is perceived as
discrimination in her attitude. I told her that she was the expert
forwarded to the Istanbul Chamber of Medicine.
inferior. As a result, trans children or adolescents who
want to wear female clothing or express themselves in
gynaecologist and that I was told she could prescribe the medication. She told she could not prescribe the medication without an
Trans people’s experiences of discrimination in regard to education
(TvT survey)
a feminine way easily become targets of transphobia.
The situation differs in many ways for trans men, but
examination. I asked her to examine me and told her that I have
In your opinion, what kind of legal or de facto measures should
wounds and need the prescription. She told me I was man, and I
be taken against such discriminatory practices experienced
told her that I had received the surgery by court order, and that
by trans individuals?
According to the survey, of the 52 respondents who
perceived as “masculine ladies”, and masculinity is ap-
she did not have the right to behave in that way because I am like
Sexual orientation and gender identity should be taken into con-
answered the question on experiences at school, 63
preciated in Turkish society. However, they benefit from
any other patient. She told me again that she would not examine
sideration in the structure and operation of all government agen-
per cent stated that their overall experience was bad.
this prejudice only as long as they live as female. If they
me because she did not approve of my situation. I told her that
cies and in all legal regulations. In order to challenge the con-
Of the 104 respondents who answered the question,
come out as a trans man, they are faced with rejection,
that was discrimination, and that I would file a complaint against
servative, binary understanding of gender, the state should be
89 per cent reported that their achievements at school
stigmatisation and discrimination, often in the form of
her. She told me to leave and to do whatever I wanted. I left the
the transformative power in this issue. I think the first and most
were not acknowledged at all. Being a trans child or ad-
rape, forced marriage or brutal violence and murder.
hospital in tears.
important step in achieving this transformation is to intervene in
olescent may mean being trapped in an endless struggle
the national education system.
for recognition.
they too face severe human-rights violations. They are
Often, because they do not have access to education,
Then I went back there in the afternoon. I explained the situa-
trans people lack qualifications for regular jobs. But in
tion calmly. The doctor again made discriminatory comments
many cases, they are university graduates and possess
and said, “I do not want to be part of this because you are on the
required qualifications but still have their job applications
wrong path”. We protested that she has no right to do this. She
rejected, or are fired if they are found out to be trans.
immediately called security, and we left.
Widespread discrimination in education and the job market pushes many trans women into the sex industry.
+ 94 +
+ 95 +